November 17, 2026

Caitlyn Jenner Rebukes Seattle Times Over Transgender Athletes Claim

A Seattle Times article claimed there is ‘no serious scientific evidence’ that transgender athletes hold a competitive edge over biological women. Caitlyn Jenner, an Olympic gold medalist and Fox News contributor, criticized this on ‘America Reports.’ She spoke with co-anchor John Roberts, defending women’s sports by highlighting physical differences and her own Olympic experiences.

The Seattle Times, on the morning after independent journalist Nick Shirley retracted his false allegation against Lam’s Seafood Asian Market in Seattle’s International District, published a story on it. Shirley’s baseless claims had put the family-owned business at risk. The paper’s role in correcting this misinformation was vital.

The Seattle School Board authorized a legal challenge to a ballot measure protecting girls’ sports. Holding journalists to account is essential, but questions arise when The Seattle Times itself makes dubious claims. Some female athletes, including Frances Staudt, Bailey Andersen, and Sadie Sullivan, shared experiences of competing against transgender athletes at a Fairness in Girls’ Sports rally in Vancouver, Washington.

On November 8, the Times published a piece to understand voter support for Initiative 638, which aims to bar biological males from competing in girls’ K-12 sports. The article presented views from both sides. However, a controversial paragraph in the article claimed no serious scientific evidence supports transgender athletes having an advantage.

Critics, including writers, provided scientific studies countering this claim. For example, a 2020 study on U.S. Air Force personnel indicated that transgender women remained 12% faster than biological females in a 1.5-mile run even after two years of hormone therapy. Investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan referenced a 2025 scientific paper showing persistent advantages in strength, power, size, and aerobic capacity even after testosterone suppression. Another review from 2020 noted transgender women typically lost just 5% of muscle mass after a year of hormone therapy.

Karen Crouse, a writer for Sport and State, cited a 2021 review showing elevated levels of strength and muscle size in transgender women after three years of hormone treatment. Additionally, a 2023 American College of Sports Medicine consensus documented the performance benefits acquired during male puberty.

Despite this, the Seattle Times has not issued a retraction or clarification. Criticism has been widespread on social media. Ryan shared a reporter’s acknowledgment of the feedback but received no formal response. Crouse reached out to editors for clarification without success. Attempts to contact the Times’ top editors and PR representative also went unanswered.

The question remains whether the paper deems this evidence as ‘serious.’ If the publisher is concerned about their credibility, ignoring peer-reviewed research contradicts their claims. It reflects either pride or cowardice. Journalists should admit their errors and strive for accountability.

Matt Calkins, a columnist focusing on sports and culture, highlights these concerns. He worked for 11 years at the Seattle Times and is known for engaging interviews and coverage. Follow him on X at matt_calkins.

TAGS: