Does a good deed matter less if the giver enjoys it, gains recognition, or receives something in return? New research suggests that these concerns are misplaced, with participants generally valuing acts of kindness regardless of selflessness.
The study, led by Ohio State University and published in the International Journal of Applied Positive Psychology, explored how people distinguish between acts they consider “kind,” “nice,” and “caring.”
“The findings let us off the hook,” said Alexia Holovatyk, a clinical psychologist with over 12 years of experience in relationship dynamics, to Newsweek. “People often hesitate to act kindly because they worry it’s not ‘pure’ enough or it’s self-serving, but this study shows that recipients don’t care about that.”
Participants largely used “kind” and “nice” interchangeably, whereas “caring” implied a deeper connection. Actions were viewed most favorably when they were warm, planned, and not expected.
When Kindness Becomes Caring
Jennifer Cheavens, the lead researcher and professor of clinical psychology, began considering this topic during student discussions in a positive psychology seminar. She used a “Friends” episode where Phoebe contests Joey’s notion that no good deed is selfless because doing good also feels good. Her students expanded on this, suggesting motivation influences whether something is “nice” or “kind.”
Cheavens collaborated with Laura Wagner, a developmental psychology professor focused on language. They conducted the largest study of its kind, creating 14 vignettes on prosocial behavior elements: anonymity, benefit, cost, expectation, planning, warmth, and the giver-receiver relationship. Participants aged 18 to 77 read scenarios and rated gestures such as holding a door or paying for food, gauging kindness, niceness, and caring.
Actions rated similarly for kindness and niceness across most dimensions, except cost. High-cost actions were deemed nicer but not necessarily kinder. Familiarity between individuals increased perceptions of caring.
Cheavens and Wagner suggested that “caring” connects more closely with emotion and companionship. Holovatyk highlighted the importance of this, especially in close relationships, noting, “Caring isn’t about the gesture’s size; it’s about feeling known by someone.”
Holovatyk noted that for people-pleasers, the study offers a lesson: “You don’t need to be perfectly selfless. Presence matters more.”
Why Feeling Good Does Not Cancel Kindness
Dr. Bonnie King, a counselor with a Ph.D. in education, noted people often hesitate to help out of fear of appearing self-serving. But the study shows others don’t judge good deeds negatively if they bring happiness to the giver. Everyday examples include checking on a friend or bringing dinner to a neighbor, found to be rated positively.
King cautioned that while the research assessed labels of actions, it didn’t explore motivations or psychological effects on the giver. Wagner proposed that feeling good after helping might encourage prosocial behavior, suggesting humans could be wired to find satisfaction in helping others to foster cooperation.
Researchers believe the findings can aid schools, clinicians, and communities in promoting prosocial behavior by aligning the terms kindness and caring with people’s expectations. Newsweek reached out to Cheavens and Wagner for further information.
Reference: Cheavens, J. S., Wagner, L. (2026). Kind, Nice, and Caring, Oh My! Investigating Differences in How Individuals Interpret Prosocial Language. International Journal of Applied Positive Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41042-026-00334-5
