During my years of reviewing theater, I have witnessed many things. But in May 2017, at the Goodman Theatre, something unprecedented occurred. On the opening night of a new play titled “Pamplona,” Stacy Keach experienced a heart attack on stage and continued performing.
Written by Jim McGarth, “Pamplona” was a solo show centered on Ernest Hemingway. The play is set in the Spanish town in 1959, and Keach was the sole performer on stage. As he portrayed Hemingway, Keach seemed to stop, then hesitantly continued. This seemed part of his intense performance.
Keach played Hemingway as a writer battling blockages at a typewriter. I initially thought his pauses added to the character’s struggle. However, I noticed some lines repeated, indicating something was amiss. Around this time, director Robert Falls left the theater suddenly, cementing my suspicion.
Keach kept performing despite the fog that he later described to me. He said, “It felt like a fog had enveloped me. It was the strangest moment.” He remained unaware of the seriousness until the stage manager intervened.
“Mr. Keach, please leave the stage,” a voice echoed. It prompted Keach to exit the stage urgently. An ambulance soon took him to Northwestern Memorial Hospital.
Reflecting on that evening, I pondered if Keach would have continued indefinitely. When asked, he admitted he would not have left voluntarily. His dedication to the performance was remarkable.
While the Tribune published an article titled “Goodman stops play as star falters,” Keach’s persistence shone through. The following year, he returned to the Goodman stage, reprising his role as Hemingway. This time, without interruptions, he truly embodied the character once more.
