November 2, 2026

Critique of ‘Adirondack Chair Circle’ at Steppenwolf Theatre

“Adirondack Chair Circle,” a play written by Stephanie Alison Walker, explores the experiences of a suburban mother who struggles to accept her child’s nonbinary identity. Directed by Pam MacKinnon, the play features Katrina Lenk in the lead role, delivering a richly expressive performance.

The play initially appears to be a moral satire, critiquing conservative viewpoints. However, the execution lacks true satirical depth. The setting, Lincoln Park, does not resonate with the portrayal of conservative book-banning figures due to the area’s liberal demographics.

The comedic elements in “Adirondack Chair Circle” often cater to the views of Steppenwolf’s core audience. This approach potentially avoids challenging them, which contradicts the theater’s historical reputation for provoking thought and self-reflection. Past works at Steppenwolf, notably during Martha Lavey and Bruce Norris’s tenure, often left audiences contemplating complex issues.

Central to the narrative is a debate among three conservative mothers over children’s literature in schools, contrasted with a liberal character advocating for librarian decisions. Caroline Neff plays the liberal character with warmth. The play, however, frames the conservative side with internal divisions, as portrayed by Sadieh Rifai, Katrina Lenk, and Wendy Mateo, yet lacks complexity on the liberal side due to a single character representation.

Opening during a contentious political campaign for Chicago’s school board, the play misses an opportunity to engage with more nuanced political tensions. It instead depicts exaggerated conservative figures summoning controversial groups, a portrayal not deeply rooted in current cultural dynamics.

Among the humorous aspects, David Darrow’s role as a crow offers comedic relief, albeit becoming repetitive. Despite engaging performances, particularly from Lenk, the play could benefit from a more profound exploration of its themes. While plays with moral or political messages hold transformative potential, effective satire requires genuine introspection.

Drawing on the wisdom of Richard Greenberg’s approach to writing, giving voice to dissenting perspectives could elevate “Adirondack Chair Circle.” Encouraging empathy for differing views might enrich its narrative depth.

Reviewed by Chris Jones

Details: “Adirondack Chair Circle” runs until December 13 at Steppenwolf’s Ensemble Theater, 1646 N. Halsted St. The performance lasts 2 hours and 30 minutes. Tickets range from $20 to $167.50.Contact: 312-335-1650 or visit steppenwolf.org

TAGS: