November 2, 2026

Ballot Controversies: Lessons from Alaska and Florida Elections

The issue of similar candidate names on a ballot is under the spotlight in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race and has similarities to Florida’s 2020 state senate contest. In Florida, a former Republican state senator was implicated in manipulating the ballot by encouraging someone with the same last name as the Democratic incumbent to run. This was meant to divert votes. The allegations in Alaska are still under investigation.

The Situation in Alaska: Two Dan Sullivans

Alaska’s ranked choice voting system has put four candidates on the upcoming ballot. The candidates include Democrat Mary Peltola, Republican Senator Dan Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. who initially filed as a Republican, and Gerald “Jerry” Heikes, also a Republican. Former President Trump has criticized the presence of another Dan Sullivan on the ballot, suggesting it is a form of cheating.

The Alaska election authority initially questioned the candidacy of Sullivan Jr., deeming it not genuine. Despite this, a court ruling reinstated his candidacy. Trump’s administration attempted to block the election results if Sullivan Jr. affected the incumbent’s votes, but a federal judge dismissed the lawsuit. It was argued that the lawsuit did not address the issue of voter confusion, and that ballot stacking, the strategy in question, is commonly legal and not considered fraud.

Florida’s 2020 Election: A Past Lesson

In Florida, two candidates with the same last name, Rodriguez, were part of the state Senate race, where a candidate believed to be a sham was thought to siphon votes. Jose Javier Rodriguez, a Democrat, lost to Republican Ileana Garcia by a narrow margin while Alex Rodriguez, the other candidate, was accused of acting as a vote siphon.

Former senator Frank Artiles was charged with recruiting Alex Rodriguez and was sentenced after being found guilty of conspiracy and other charges. Alex Rodriguez admitted to receiving money for his candidacy, which led to his guilty plea. Garcia, not involved in the scheme, retained her position and later criticized Trump’s policies.

Lessons for Alaska’s Race

Florida’s cases provide insights into the Alaska situation. A candidate’s candidacy is legal unless financial incentives are involved. No such claims have surfaced in Alaska’s case involving Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. Experts suggest that encouraging someone to run doesn’t violate Alaska’s laws.

Alaska election officials assert that they have sufficiently distinguished between the two Dan Sullivans. Senator Sullivan is marked as “incumbent” and “Republican” whereas Sullivan Jr. has no party affiliation. The ranked choice voting system helps mitigate vote splitting by allowing voters to rank candidates, ensuring their preferences are considered.

TAGS: