November 2, 2026

Judge Orders Release of Canadian Dentist Detained by ICE Due to Mistaken Address

A Ruling on Immigration Mistakes

In a significant legal decision, U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis has instructed immigration authorities in Minnesota to immediately free William Virgil Lizardo. He is a Canadian dentist detained by ICE following an incorrect immigration hearing notice being dispatched to an outdated address. Davis ruled this as a violation of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments, highlighting the substantial risk of erroneous deprivation of Lizardo’s liberty. The judge’s November 1 order criticized USCIS for admitting its mistake without providing relief, calling the case’s details ‘appalling.’

Details of Lizardo’s Experience

Lizardo must be released by 6 p.m. Sunday in Minnesota under Davis’s order which also prevents future detention, transfer, or removal without court consent. The order underscores ongoing tensions between federal judges and the Trump administration regarding ICE’s authority, specifically concerning due process. DHS rulings on immigration restrictions have faced criticism for allegedly exceeding judicial powers.

Lizardo came to the U.S. in 2019 on a student visa attending the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry, graduating in 2023. He married a U.S. citizen from his dental class and they have a daughter born in 2025. The filing of the alien relative petition for permanent residency in September 2023 was approved in January 2025.

Lizardo was active in dentistry both professionally and volunteer-wise until his work authorization was revoked. His residency application was denied due to a missing Ontario court record of a dismissed 2012 charge. An appeal is pending as Lizardo continues legal efforts against unjust immigration impediments.

Meltdown Over Miscommunication

Shortly after a DHS-issued court appearance notice was wrongly sent to an old address, Lizardo missed the March 26 hearing. He became aware only by October 23 at an immigration interview with his lawyer present, resulting in his arrest and imprisonment.

The immigration court agreed to reopen proceedings on October 28, revoking the removal order post evidence of non-receipt of notice. Federal arguments to dismiss based on procedural reopening were denied by Davis, finding no new warrant justifying detention and insufficient evidence of flight risk.

Judge’s Observations and Conditions

The judge praised Lizardo’s history of compliance with immigration procedures and maintained familial and communal connections, rejecting the notion of him fleeing. Davis ordered Lizardo’s release on his recognizance, returning his belongings and barring re-detention sans court approval. Future detentions require clear evidence ensuring his presence and safety aspects, burdening the government with proving necessity.

The ruling doesn’t confer Lizardo permanent residency, with immigration procedures still open following the removal order’s revocation.

TAGS: