A multimillion-dollar defamation lawsuit filed by President Trump against The Wall Street Journal has been dismissed. U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles in Miami ruled against the suit, citing insufficient evidence of defamatory statements made with actual malice.
The lawsuit stemmed from a story by the Wall Street Journal reporting on Trump’s alleged ties to a birthday album prepared for Jeffrey Epstein. Judge Gayles described the lawsuit as “grasping at straws” in its attempts to challenge the Journal’s investigative work.
Actual Malice Explained
To win a defamation suit involving a public figure, the plaintiff must prove that harmful statements were published either with knowledge of their falsity or with disregard for their truth. The dismissal “with prejudice” means the case cannot be reopened or refiled.
A spokesperson for Trump’s legal team stated that they would continue to pursue accountability against the Wall Street Journal and other defendants, although an appeal is likely, according to sources familiar with Trump’s legal strategy.
The Wall Street Journal article, published last year, discussed a sexually suggestive letter believed to bear Trump’s name included in an album for Epstein’s 50th birthday. Trump labeled the article as “FAKE” and initiated a $20 billion lawsuit targeting the paper, News Corp, its CEO, the reporters, and Rupert Murdoch.
Later, lawmakers subpoenaed and obtained a redacted version of the birthday book from Epstein’s estate, containing the letter central to Trump’s lawsuit. The then-White House press secretary stated Trump neither drew nor signed the picture.
Judge Gayles had previously dismissed the suit in April, finding that Trump’s legal team did not meet the required standard to prove actual malice. Despite a refiling attempt, the lawsuit faced the same outcome.
