A man from New Hampshire, Douglas Herlihy, faces a prison sentence of up to 24 years after admitting to the murder of his father more than two decades ago. Herlihy, now 40, confessed to the crime that occurred when he was 17, according to the New Hampshire Department of Justice.
The relationship between Douglas and his father, Paul Herlihy, was marked by conflict, including past violence and police involvement. Paul Herlihy, 50, was discovered dead on August 27, 2003, during a welfare check prompted by a relative’s concern. His body was found in his Milford, New Hampshire home, wrapped in carpet and covered by a blue tarp.
When officers entered through a window, they noticed numerous flies and a strong odor of decomposition. Blood spatters were found on kitchen surfaces, including cabinets, the refrigerator, and walls. An autopsy confirmed that Paul Herlihy’s death resulted from blunt-force trauma. His injuries included a broken nose and jaw, skull fractures, and damage to his voice box, indicating severe head trauma.
At the scene, investigators found blood-stained carpet and padding in the backyard, which had been pushed out of Douglas Herlihy’s bedroom window. DNA evidence suggested the blood belonged to Paul Herlihy. Inside Douglas’s room, a closet door, concealed by a towel, displayed the words, ‘I WILL SEE YOU IN HELL,’ written in large letters according to the affidavit.
Following the crime, Douglas Herlihy had multiple legal issues, including drug and stolen vehicle charges. In a 2020 arrest, he allegedly told an officer he had beaten a murder case at 17, implying involvement in his father’s death. Despite these remarks, Herlihy always denied killing his father to family and in court.
Detectives approached Herlihy in 2010 about the case, and he referred them to his lawyer. An arrest warrant was issued in June 2025, and Herlihy was arrested in Saugus, Massachusetts before extradition to New Hampshire.
Douglas Herlihy was charged with second-degree murder and falsifying evidence, ultimately arranging a plea deal for a manslaughter charge resulting in a 12 to 24-year sentence. A potential 3 ½ to 7-year sentence for evidence falsification was suspended for 20 years.
Attorney General John M. Formella emphasized that justice remains consistent over time. He praised the Cold Case Unit’s dedication to finding answers and accountability regardless of timing.
A sentencing hearing is set for early 2027. The Herlihy family has opted for privacy and declined media inquiries.
