October 21, 2026

Preventing School Violence: A Public Health Approach

keeping our schools safe

This article was originally published after the school shooting in 2018 at Parkland, Florida. Following the tragedy, many proposed making schools more secure by arming teachers. However, research shows that increasing guns in schools may not enhance safety.

After the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting, Matthew Mayer of Rutgers received an email from Shane Jimerson at the University of California, Santa Barbara. Both experts in school violence, they took part in developing an eight-point action plan to prevent gun violence in the U.S.

This plan, supported by about 200 universities and over 2,300 experts, emphasizes improving social and emotional health instead of hardening schools with more security measures. Ron Avi Astor from the University of Southern California advocates for a public health model, focusing on community engagement and preventing problems before they escalate.

The Public Health Approach

The public health strategy involves proactive measures. This means enhancing the general environment by addressing issues like bullying and discrimination. Such methods can help in de-escalating potential conflicts. Experts suggest the removal of major hazards contributing to gun violence, namely guns. The comprehensive plan includes universal background checks, banning assault weapons, and introducing Gun Violence Protection Orders.

A Shift in Strategy

Traditional security measures, such as armed officers and metal detectors, show limited effectiveness. Mayer believes that true prevention requires a more comprehensive approach. Key elements include fostering positive school climates, which involve the quality of relationships among students and staff. A strong school environment links to better mental and emotional health for students.

Studies by Astor and others indicate that an improved school climate reduces violence. Troubled students require attention, and schools should connect with community resources to support them. Globally, the link between carrying weapons and experiencing victimization is evident. Proactive measures aim to resolve these issues before they escalate.

The Role of Witnesses

A positive school climate encourages students to report threats. In California, surveys reveal that numerous students witness weapons at school. Yet, many do not report incidents if they lack strong relationships with adults. Astor urges schools to use education as an intervention, addressing not just major incidents but everyday violence.

Preventing gun violence also includes addressing suicide, a leading cause of death for teenagers. A strong school climate approach handles potential self-harm effectively as well.

Policy and Emergency Interventions

The eight-point policy plan proposes nationwide assessments of school climate, reductions in suspensions and expulsions, creating safe schools, and hiring counselors and mental health professionals. When a weapon or violent intent is reported, the public health approach suggests conducting threat assessments.

Post-Columbine research by the FBI and the Secret Service highlighted the need for schools to adopt threat assessment procedures used for government officials. Many schools, including all in Virginia since 2013, use this method. It involves a school team evaluating threats and involves parents, mental health, and law enforcement when necessary.

While not fail-proof, studies support threat assessments in reducing suspensions and bullying, and fostering safer school environments. Less than 1% of threats lead to violence when threat assessments are properly conducted. Despite setbacks, the researchers urge attention to newer evidence-based approaches and hope for broader implementation this time.

TAGS: