The experiences of the Greatest Generation during the 1930s and 1940s revealed the existence of pervasive evil on a large scale. Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, and Imperial Japan demonstrated this harsh reality. Their defeat required immense global sacrifices during the Second World War. However, the end of the war did not eliminate threats of world domination by totalitarian regimes. Instead, the Soviet Union and its allies continued these ambitions, albeit under a new banner.
Despite the rise of this new threat, the advent of nuclear arms made the prospect of a third world war increasingly untenable for Western society. Yet the Soviet Union often flaunted its nuclear capabilities to deter Western intervention as it expanded communist ideology across Europe, Asia, Africa, and the Americas. The postwar period saw the U.S. belatedly recognize the dangers of communist expansion. In response, President Truman directed Secretary of State Dean Acheson in January 1950 to outline the U.S. national security interests in Asia. Acheson detailed a security perimeter, notably excluding Taiwan and South Korea.
Meanwhile, Stalin, Mao Zedong, and Kim Il Sung debated the next target for communist expansion. In June 1950, Kim acted first by launching an invasion of South Korea. The North’s aggressive move prompted a response from the United Nations, leading to a ‘police action’ initiated by President Truman. This approach veered away from ‘unconditional surrender’ and ‘regime change,’ focusing instead on containing aggression. The Korean War introduced the notion of ‘limited war,’ in which retaliation against major powers supplying lesser aggressors was minimized.
Over seventy years later, North Korea remains part of an axis identified by President George W. Bush in 2002, comprising Iran, Iraq, and North Korea. Russia and China, aligning their interests with Iran and North Korea, present a formidable challenge. Western nations must consider their strategies in response to Iran’s current activities.
One approach for the U.S. and its allies involves continuing with negotiations, economic sanctions, and selective military interventions to counter Iran’s nuclear ambitions and its quest for regional dominance. However, this approach might result in a prolonged and resource-consuming confrontation. Americans, already weary from extended military engagements, have limited patience for such standoffs.
Another option would involve capitulating to Iranian control of strategic locations, such as the Gulf of Hormuz. While this might avoid immediate conflict, it would severely undermine international maritime laws and potentially incite aggression from other players, like China in the Taiwan Strait.
The third potential response is revisiting the initial instincts of former President Trump, recognizing the Islamic Republic’s pursuit as irredeemably hostile. Eliminating the regime could open doors for a more democratic Iran, akin to past transitions seen in World War II and later with Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. This would necessitate robust, coordinated communication efforts reminiscent of Cold War strategies, empowering Iranian citizens with truthful information and encouraging internal dissent.
Such a campaign, thoroughly coordinated and well-supported, might trigger defections within the Iranian military and government. Historical precedents from World War II saw resistance movements bolstered by Allied support. Similarly, a movement in Iran, if supported appropriately, could usher in its liberation and embrace of global norms.
Yet, the potential role of former President Trump or his successor in leading this charge is uncertain. If mishandled, history might not view current leadership kindly, drawing unfavorable parallels to past leaders who underestimated looming threats.
Joseph Bosco, with experience in the U.S. Defense Department and affiliations with various institutes, provides this perspective.
© 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. Redistribution or rewriting of this content is prohibited.
