Vice President JD Vance addressed the media on Thursday, invoking Senator Bernie Sanders’ historical stance against open borders. Vance’s comments came in defense of the Trump administration’s recent immigration crackdown and served to critique self-described socialists in the U.S. These remarks underscore an unexpected concurrence between two ideologically opposite politicians.
The Trump administration is moving to suspend certain companies from a crucial employment-based immigration pathway. Additionally, it is indicating intensified scrutiny of visa programs favored by businesses and universities.
Vance Highlights Past Statements
During a press conference announcing enforcement actions against firms accused of abusing employment visa programs, Vance reflected on how socialist politicians have, in his view, shifted away from a historical worker-focused perspective.
“It’s funny, back in 2016, one of the most interesting things that happened was when Bernie Sanders, then, of course, the leading socialist in the United States of America, was asked about open borders,” Vance told Newsweek. “He gave an answer that sounded similar to Stephen Miller’s, where he said, of course, we’re not going to have open borders because that’s going to displace American workers.”
Vance argues the modern American left has diverged from that position. For him, immigration policies should emphasize U.S. workers’ welfare over foreign labor competition.
Vance’s remarks also followed the Trump administration’s decision to suspend companies like Microsoft, Adobe, and several IT outsourcing firms from the Labor Department’s PERM program. This program enables employers to sponsor foreign workers for permanent residency.
Skepticism Over Labor Market Impact
The administration alleges Microsoft laid off approximately 6,000 American workers while employing around 6,300 non-citizens via H-1B visas. Officials accuse some companies of using these programs to replace domestic workers with cheaper foreign labor.
Vance suggested Sanders once shared similar concerns regarding labor-market impacts. He believes Sanders’ earlier rejection of open borders indicated fears about potential negative effects on wages and jobs for American workers.
Vance further noted, “It’s honestly, it’s a hard term to define these days, referring to socialism. Very often socialism, classically, you would think socialism is about prioritizing workers.”
Bernie Sanders on Border Security
Though Sanders is a leading figure among American progressives, he has differentiated between supporting immigration reform and endorsing open borders. Throughout his campaigns, Sanders emphasized the importance of maintaining functioning borders while advocating for comprehensive humanitarian and economic reforms.
Sanders consistently argues for secure borders, promoting legal status and pathways to citizenship for millions of undocumented immigrants already in the U.S. He has endorsed enhanced technological use and personnel at the border while opposing expansive wall construction as the main enforcement mechanism.
This is an ongoing story, with more developments anticipated.
