Dig promises a fresh look for viewers seeking signs of cultural shifts post-elections. Announced last spring, it premieres its 10-episode first season on November 23. The show reunites Amy Poehler and Michael Schur, creators of the popular Parks and Recreation. Instead of mirroring current trends, Dig escapes the pressure of staying relevant, weaving escapism into its story like patterns on ancient pottery.
Originating from a novel by Kate Myers and adapted by Poehler and Schur, Dig follows a group of archaeologists in Greece. They spend summers uncovering artifacts under the hot sun. While it is primarily a workplace comedy, a genre Schur knows well from his work on Brooklyn Nine-Nine and The Office, the show also explores romance and mystery. The show struggles with some miscasting and lacks consistent stakes, preventing it from reaching the high bar set by Parks and Rec. Nonetheless, with its engaging characters and unique setting, Dig offers a rewarding viewing experience.
Characters and Casting
A notable element of Dig is its diverse cast, spanning multiple generations, a rarity in many TV workplace settings. Hugh Laurie plays Neville Wycombe, an elder archaeologist with plans to retire. He intends to promote his competent deputy, Elise (played by Poehler). “If I have one concern, it’s about your demeanor,” he tells her. As the leader of a team relying on youthful labor, creating a satisfying work environment is key. Neville excels at this, but Elise’s motto is, “Work hard and never have fun.”
The show centers on female characters. Geraldine Viswanathan stands out as Dylan, whose return to the dig from an abrupt past departure brings tension. Attempting to mend her relationship with both her mentor Elise and former boyfriend Gary, Dylan finds Gary now engaged to Clare, portrayed by Antonia Thomas. Clare’s dedication and reserved nature contrast with Dylan’s impulsiveness.
Neville’s teenage assistant Patty, played by Fina Strazza, adds comedic relief to the ensemble. When Elise fails to inspire the young diggers, Neville’s intervention secures his return for another season, leading to intrigue among the team. Soon, a secret discovery by Elise and Dylan adds to the mounting tensions on-site.
Comedy, Romance, and Dynamics
The characters discuss Elise as someone underestimated yet powerful, differentiating her from Poehler’s previous roles. Suggestions that Kathryn Hahn or Lizzy Caplan would fit the role highlight the mismatch, as Poehler brings more cheerfulness than edge. Smart writing and clever twists occasionally slip into predictable territory when romance should take center stage.
Elise and Stavros share humorous miscommunications, exemplified by his phrase about her “behind that continues to be employed.” However, his character lacks depth beyond stereotypical traits. The love triangle among Dylan, Gary, and Clare lacks the chemistry seen in Schur’s prior works, such as Parks and Rec or The Good Place, which depicted sweet partnerships.
Theme and Potential
Dig doesn’t anchor itself with specific themes. Unlike Schur’s other shows, which engaged deeply with societal issues or philosophical queries, Dig might benefit from exploring themes such as the passion for archaeology and preserving past human endeavors.
Nevertheless, there is an opportunity for growth. Schur’s other successful shows witnessed crucial developments early on, enriching character depth and viewer connection. Dig has potential, with its focus on intergenerational female friendships being a strong foundation. If future seasons adjust the romance focus, building on its fresh premise and existing charm, the show could thrive alongside its lively characters.
