Uncategorized
November 19, 2026

Community Rallies After Burglary Spree Hits Evanston and Wilmette

Pat Fowler, the owner of Bluestone sports bar in Evanston, found himself dealing with an unexpected challenge as his restaurant’s 25th anniversary approached. His establishment, along with eight other businesses on Central Street in Evanston and 16 businesses in Wilmette, fell victim to an overnight burglary on Nov. 12. Within less than 30 minutes, several store windows were shattered as multiple offenders tried to steal cash, reported by police and store surveillance.

Though only a few hundred dollars were taken from Bluestone, Fowler estimates repairs will cost around $8,000. “The cost of the damage and an insurance claim isn’t worth it, so it’s going to come from my pocket,” he shared with Pioneer Press. Yet the community’s response has been heartwarming.

Valerie Kahan, owner of Evanston Art Makers Outpost, was moved to act. As a fellow small business owner, she understood the impact of property crime on a community. “When people see boarded-up shops, it affects morale,” she said. Determined to bring positivity back, Kahan, alongside her friend Tara, initiated a community-driven project. They raised funds to create and print 11 posters filled with supportive and humorous messages.

Phrases like “Excuse the Plywood, We’re Still Making Magic Inside” and “Glass Breaks. Community Doesn’t. We’re Open!!” now adorn windows on Central Street, lifting spirits and drawing visitors.

Businesses have reported increased foot traffic since displaying these signs. Fowler, along with Ellen King of Hewn Bakery and Julie Heinz of Preston’s Florist, noted the neighborhood’s encouraging response. “It’s nice to be part of a supportive community,” stated King, who experienced the burglary attempt while bakers were present at her shop.

Other impacted businesses include Pinto Thai, The Christian Science Reading Room, Custom Eyes, Mustard’s Last Stand, The Spot, and The Spice House in Evanston. In Wilmette, Pit & Tap, Central Station Coffee & Tea, Panera Bread, and Cocomero Frozen Yogurt were targeted. Evanston police responded to reported burglar alarms and broken windows shortly after 4 a.m. on Nov. 12.

Commander Chelsea Brown noted the affected stores span the 1600 to 1900 blocks of Central Street. In Wilmette, nine businesses in the 100 block of Skokie Boulevard and seven in the Village Center faced burglaries. Wilmette Village Manager Michael Braiman announced that police recovered all cash registers with original contents and plan to release an investigation update soon.

The Evanston Police Department is collaborating with other agencies as the investigation continues. Brown mentioned preliminary findings suggest the suspects operated from a single vehicle reportedly stolen from Oak Forest. Officers encountered the vehicle near Village Center, but the driver evaded capture by merging onto the I-94 expressway. Chicago police later located the vehicle, observing offenders fleeing on foot.

Despite these events, Fowler and other business owners remain confident about their community’s resilience. “It’s happened before, but community support and police response have been reassuring,” added Heinz, reflecting on her 45 years with Preston’s Florist.

TAGS: