November 17, 2026

Criticism Follows NYC Mayor’s Decision to Dissolve Police Counterterror Unit

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing backlash after announcing plans to dissolve the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, replacing it with a civilian-led division focused on dialogue and de-escalation. The new unit will not have weapons or arrest powers, aiming to separate counterterrorism from protest response. Mamdani emphasized the importance of New Yorkers being able to protest without facing a police response meant for terrorism threats.

The Strategic Response Group was established in 2015 to handle terrorism and manage protest crowds. Mamdani reaffirmed that police could still be asked to make arrests, including those involved in civil disobedience. The new civilian-led unit will be staffed with 30 trained officers and will seek to prioritize communication during protests.

NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch expressed concerns over the changes, asserting that they would not compromise the department’s ability to protect citizens. Meanwhile, some city council members and Jewish community leaders voiced strong opposition, fearing the dissolution of the SRG could endanger Jewish communities in particular.

Critics referenced recent incidents involving anti-Semitic protests and violence, arguing that the SRG was instrumental in controlling such threats. Inna Vernikov and Evan R. Bernstein highlighted the risks the new approach might pose to the Jewish community, noting significant increases in anti-Jewish hate crimes. They criticized the civilian unit’s lack of enforcement abilities.

Mamdani’s decision follows demands from anti-Israel groups to disband the SRG. Previous protests outside Jewish institutions, which led to arrests, underscored the ongoing tensions. Jewish leaders worry that the new strategies could unintentionally exacerbate vulnerabilities. Despite these concerns, the World Jewish Congress expressed confidence in the NYPD’s continued protection.

Moshe Davis, formerly of the mayor’s office to combat Jew-hatred, stressed the need for more police and swifter responses to protect communities. He conveyed skepticism about the effectiveness of Mamdani’s rebranding effort, while some political commentators criticized the move as potentially increasing chaos.

TAGS: