A judge in Alaska ruled that Mary Peltola’s campaign cannot access a list of absentee voters whose ballots were rejected. The request was deemed “not reasonable” due to the ongoing counting of ballots from last week’s ranked vote election.
Peltola, a Democratic U.S. Senate candidate, and Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan are the main contenders in a race still too close to call. Alaska election rules allow accepting ballots from overseas voters up to 15 days after the election, setting Nov. 18 as the deadline. If no candidate receives more than 50% of first-choice votes, ranked choice tabulations will occur then.
The campaign’s attorneys filed a lawsuit seeking the list of rejected absentee voters and reasons for rejections. They aimed to ensure all qualified absentee votes are counted. However, state attorneys countered that such a list would breach voter privacy. They argued producing the list from the voter database qualifies as an “electronic service or product,” which state law deems secondary to the main electoral duties.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews acknowledged in his written decision that records could theoretically be redacted and shared to protect privacy. Yet, he ruled that the Division of Elections isn’t obliged to release these records, as they can’t be produced or redacted easily amid the ongoing election process.
Matthews described the timing of the request as problematic, noting the division’s staff is working extended hours to manage the election.
Abha Khanna, an attorney for Peltola’s campaign, argued in court that their intent wasn’t to interrupt the ballot count and noted the process was advancing smoothly. Khanna stated the desired information aligns with existing access given to campaign observers. Yet, she sought centralized access to enhance monitoring.
State attorneys have claimed that reports listing ballots under review aren’t public documents, citing confidential details. Michaela Thompson, managing absentee ballot reviews, explained that reports available to campaign observers include necessary voter addresses for the election process. Observers sign confidentiality agreements to maintain privacy.
Thompson noted the division’s outdated database could not generate a report omitting confidential addresses without vendor assistance, revealing logistical constraints in fulfilling the campaign’s request.
