November 11, 2026

Minnesota and Oregon: A Tale of Two Regional Governments

Two significant problems faced by major US metro areas are racial inequality and climate change. Planning scholars have believed that regional government and planning play vital roles in addressing these issues. However, creating such governments has proven difficult in most locations.

In the 1960s and 1970s, Minnesota and Oregon succeeded in establishing regional governments for their largest metro areas: the Metropolitan Council in the Twin Cities and Metro in the Portland region. These bodies aimed to curb urban sprawl, manage traffic congestion, and protect open spaces. They also sought to prevent social, economic, and fiscal isolation of central cities from surrounding suburbs.

Both governments introduced metro growth boundaries and fair-share housing systems. Each municipal community had to accommodate its share of the region’s need for affordable housing. This was intended to ensure healthy development within the boundaries and limited external development.

A study by the Institute on Metropolitan Opportunity at the University of Minnesota reports substantial progress by Portland’s Metro Council in reducing racial inequality and average household driving. Portland residents drive one-third fewer miles per year, leading to lower greenhouse gas emissions. In contrast, the Twin Cities experience rising racial segregation, despite following similar policies.

Demographically, both areas are about two-thirds white and exhibit low poverty rates. They have witnessed steady population growth. Between 2000 and 2020, the Twin Cities expanded its metro boundary twice as fast as Portland, failing to contain urban sprawl effectively.

Since 2000, the Twin Cities added 19% more freeway lanes per capita than Portland. Portland has been more successful at enforcing fair-share requirements. In Portland’s developed suburbs, 38% of housing units are rentals, compared to 26% in the Twin Cities. Single-family lot sizes are smaller in Portland, enabling diverse housing options.

Lack of affordable suburban housing contributes to Minneapolis and St. Paul’s social and economic distress, much more than in Portland. The Twin Cities’ distressed neighborhoods are notably larger and expanding, while Portland’s are shrinking. This situation impacts school choices, with few middle-class families opting for schools in such areas.

Portland’s neighborhoods offer mixed-income schools with desirable test scores. Despite equal percentages of white students, the Twin Cities have 189 schools with more than 90% nonwhite students, while Portland has just one. Larger areas of social distress in the Twin Cities correlate with higher urban crime rates. Minneapolis has an 83% higher murder rate than Portland, and the violent crime rate is 43% higher.

The central city growth in Portland outpaces Minneapolis by 2.6 times and is three times higher than St. Paul. This increase in middle-class households and businesses has expanded Portland’s tax base per capita, allowing for better municipal services and lower taxes. In contrast, Minneapolis and St. Paul have slower tax base growth and greater impoverishment in schools and neighborhoods.

If the Twin Cities’ Met Council enforced its regulations, the region could become more racially equitable, strengthen cities and older suburbs, and more effectively tackle climate change.

Most US regions lack the political will to establish regional planning frameworks, and such an achievement remains significant. The new governor of Minnesota should ensure that the Twin Cities utilize this legacy effectively.

Myron Orfield is the Earl R. Larson Professor of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Law at the University of Minnesota and directs the Institute on Metropolitan Opportunity.

TAGS: