November 11, 2026

Impeachment Attempts Targeting Defense Officials and Historical Precedents

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth narrowly avoided impeachment after the Republican-led House voted against a resolution by a GOP lawmaker. The measure was defeated with a 211-204 vote, introduced by Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky. The accusations stated violations of the War Powers Resolution of 1973 due to insufficient congressional oversight on the Iran war, which Massie called “unlawful from its inception.” Additional charges included ignoring laws aimed at minimizing civilian casualties and the alleged “kidnapping of a sovereign foreign leader,” referring to the capture of former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro.

Hegseth characterized the impeachment effort as a political show, denouncing Massie’s resolutions as a “farce” that undermined the Constitution. During a press conference, he maintained that operations in Iran, against drug cartels, and with Venezuela were legally conducted under orders from the Commander in Chief, and subsequently reported to Congress. Even if the House had passed the measure, obtaining a two-thirds majority in the current Republican-controlled Senate would have been challenging.

Looking ahead, Democrats might revisit impeachment efforts in January when they gain control of both the House and Senate after sweeping midterm victories. For now, Hegseth retains President Donald Trump’s support, with Trump promising to stand with him even if impeachment were to proceed. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries supports the impeachment effort and might play a significant role if another resolution is submitted against Hegseth upon assuming the role of House Speaker.

If convicted, impeachment disqualifies from future federal office. Thomas Berry from the Cato Institute notes the parallel to criminal law, saying, “An impeachment vote is like an indictment. It signals sufficient evidence of high crimes or misdemeanors to warrant a trial.”

The House has initiated impeachment proceedings more than 60 times, leading to formal impeachment in 22 cases involving 21 individuals. Former President Trump faced impeachment twice during his first term, in 2020 and 2021, but was acquitted by the Senate on both occasions.

Historical Context: William Belknap’s Impeachment

Secretary of War William Belknap, serving from 1869 to 1876 under President Ulysses S. Grant, was the first Cabinet secretary impeached. Under scrutiny after Democrats gained a House majority in 1875, Belknap faced investigations into financial corruption within the Grant Administration.

Belknap was accused of accepting bribes and engaging in kickback schemes involving military trading posts. His tenure ended abruptly when he resigned hours before the House voted unanimously to impeach him in 1876. Despite his resignation, Senate proceedings continued, debating whether a trial could proceed post-resignation.

The Senate acquitted Belknap, not reaching the required two-thirds majority for conviction, leaving the constitutional question of post-office impeachment proceedings unresolved.

Recent Impeachment: Alejandro Mayorkas

The impeachment of DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas in 2024 highlighted the delicate balance between policy disagreements and impeachable offenses. Republicans accused Mayorkas of neglecting immigration law enforcement. However, without a major scandal similar to Belknap’s, the case questioned the boundaries of impeachment.

Senate Democrats quickly dismissed Mayorkas’ impeachment as unconstitutional, emphasizing the dangers of transforming policy disagreements into grounds for removal from office. The Biden Administration criticized the move, arguing that impeachment should not punish policy decisions made in good faith.

Mayorkas described the proceedings as groundless, continuing to lead the DHS until a new administration took office in January 2025.

TAGS: