Several Republican lawmakers expressed anger over President Donald Trump’s decision to appoint Stephen Miller as his chief of staff. Representative Marlin Stutzman of Indiana labeled the decision as a “horrible” choice.
An anonymous Republican lawmaker told Fox News Digital they were in “utter disbelief” over the promotion. Tensions were high as Republicans faced a poor showing in the midterm elections. Many House Republicans argued that Miller, known for leading Trump’s immigration policy, should have been dismissed rather than promoted.
Trump Names Stephen Miller New White House Chief of Staff, Replacing Susie Wiles
Stephen Miller, who previously served as deputy chief of staff for policy, had faced significant criticism. The Republicans lost both the House and Senate to the Democrats, with the latter set to claim over 250 House seats and at least 54 Senate seats.
Voter analysis suggested Trump’s military intervention in Iran and tariff policies were major factors in turning voters away. Additionally, his immigration policies alienated key demographics, particularly Hispanic and Latino voters in traditionally conservative states like Texas.
Because of his immigration positions, I think we ruined a lot of our goodwill with Latino voters,” Stutzman said.
A second GOP lawmaker stated that Miller had disregarded multiple warnings from House members about the negative impact of his immigration enforcement policies.
Some Republicans believed Miller’s actions, especially regarding immigration, harmed the party’s standings. Retiring Representative Don Bacon of Nebraska notes that Miller’s strategies may have cost the party several seats in the elections.
I think he’s greatly hurt the administration and cost us many seats on Tuesday,” said Bacon.
Miller is closely associated with Trump’s immigration agenda, including managing the administration’s response to anti-immigration protests. Despite criticisms, Trump justified the appointment by highlighting Miller’s record as a trusted advisor.
Some Republicans noted that other administration officials, like Secretary of War Pete Hegseth, also faced blame for the election outcomes. However, the president himself and his circle attributed the losses to candidate quality rather than policy or strategy.
In a Truth Social post announcing Miller’s promotion, Trump praised him as a “most trusted advisor” and predicted Miller would excel in his new role.
White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis described Miller as instrumental in advancing Trump’s “America First agenda.” She credited him with achievements in crime reduction, deregulation, and energy policy, stating Miller would continue to deliver substantial results.
Vice President JD Vance praised Miller’s patriotism and predicted his success. House Freedom Caucus Chairman Andy Harris emphasized Miller’s record on border security and crime.
A White House official also pointed out Miller’s collaboration with Democrats on local initiatives and his longstanding role as a valued aide since 2016.
