The Supreme Court’s conservative majority appeared inclined to support a decision allowing a state-funded pre-K program to exclude four-year-old children of gay and trans parents. This potential ruling could affect Colorado’s program, established in 2022, which aims to provide early education to all children of this age. The program is taxpayer-funded at an annual cost of $6,300 per child and is open to religious groups, provided they comply with state non-discrimination laws.
Initially, the Catholic Church backed the program, with Catholic Charities still participating. However, the Denver archdiocese contends that adhering to the non-discrimination mandate infringes on religious rights guaranteed by the Constitution. The archdiocese seeks an exemption to receive funding while excluding children of gay and trans parents.
During deliberations, conservative justices seemed favorable toward the archdiocese’s request. Justice Neil Gorsuch questioned if Colorado was flouting past court rulings. Justice Amy Coney Barrett expressed skepticism about Colorado’s motives. Justice Brett Kavanaugh suggested the law creates unnecessary conflict, noting abundant alternatives to the 34 Catholic schools in the state.
Justice Samuel Alito argued there is insufficient evidence proving LGBTQ couples struggle to find other preschools. Countering, Colorado Deputy Solicitor General Helen Norton highlighted specific examples illustrating the non-interchangeability of these schools for some families due to practical needs.
The liberal justices strongly opposed their conservative counterparts. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson emphasized lack of a foundational difference between barring children based on parental sexual orientation and race. Justice Elena Kagan critiqued the perceived need for special accommodations for religious entities. Justice Sonia Sotomayor confronted the archdiocese’s lawyer about discrimination against children with homosexual parents.
Among conservatives, Chief Justice John Roberts was the only one to express any reservation about the archdiocese’s position. All six conservative justices, along with liberal Justice Sotomayor, are of Catholic upbringing. A decision on the case is anticipated by summer 2027.
