The Trump administration is planning changes to federal workplace pregnancy rules. These changes could affect how the government handles miscarriage-related accommodations at work. Current Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) rules cover workers needing time off or adjustments due to a miscarriage. Emerging research suggests workplace pregnancy accommodations may reduce miscarriage rates.
The unknown element is whether the administration will maintain miscarriage protections when introducing a new definition under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA). The EEOC is preparing to propose changes to its interpretation of ‘pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions,’ which define the law’s scope. This definition currently includes miscarriages, stillbirths, and abortions.
As of Wednesday, the exact details of these changes have not appeared in the Federal Register. Newsweek has reached out to the EEOC and White House for comments.
How the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act Protects Against Miscarriage
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, effective June 2023, obliges employers to consider reasonable accommodations for workers with known pregnancy-related limitations unless these accommodations cause undue hardship. According to EEOC guidance, the law covers employees needing time off due to a miscarriage. It treats miscarriage and stillbirth as pregnancy-related medical conditions.
Megan Thomas, a sexual harassment and employment law attorney, highlights the need for workplace flexibility for those recovering from a miscarriage. This may include flexible schedules, the ability to work from home, or requiring lighter duties.
Could Rule Changes Affect Miscarriage Protections?
There isn’t enough public information to determine if miscarriage will be excluded. The EEOC intends to revise the definition but has not disclosed new language. Current regulations protect pregnancy-related conditions, including miscarriage. Miscarriage might be most impacted by a narrower PWFA rule, argues Brianna Williams, founder of Mélange | A Williams Firm.
Williams notes that while regulations can’t rewrite the law passed by Congress, they affect workplace accommodation decisions. Despite possible changes, other federal laws, like the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), may offer some protection, but not equivalent rights.
Research on Workplace Accommodations and Miscarriage Risk
Research from the University of Wisconsin-Madison suggests a 9.6% reduction in miscarriages with workplace pregnancy accommodations, alongside a 3.2% increase in live births. This does not prove individual miscarriages result from denied accommodations. Williams suggests physical strain as a possible explanation but refrains from asserting reasons for specific miscarriage instances.
Challenges for Physically Demanding Jobs
Workers in physically demanding and lower-wage jobs could face challenges with reduced pregnancy-related accommodations. They often can’t work remotely or afford unpaid time off. Megan Thomas emphasizes that workers in physically demanding jobs, such as warehouses and hospitals, most need these accommodations.
Williams highlights that strict attendance policies might lead to termination for workers recovering from a miscarriage, which the PWFA aims to protect.
Next Steps for the Administration’s Rule Change
The next step is the publication of the proposed EEOC regulation. The Unified Agenda schedules a proposal for this month with a public-comment period closing in January. Whether ‘miscarriage’ remains in the regulations will be telling. Thomas and Breiter suggest scrutinizing how the proposal affects practical rights to accommodations post-miscarriage.
Additionally, the treatment of abortion provisions will be critical, given the overlap in care methods with miscarriages, as pointed out by Williams. The forthcoming regulation will determine if miscarriage remains an integral part of federal workplace guarantees.
