In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court addressed public-sector unions with a decision in Janus v. AFSCME. The court ruled that government employees should not be forced to financially support a union as a condition of employment. Eight years later, the question arises whether the court will uphold this decision. So far, there has been no further action. However, two current lawsuits might push the court to revisit the issue.
Oregon and New York have recently implemented similar laws. These laws appear to aim at preventing fraudulent impersonation of labor unions. While preventing fraud seems valid, these laws specifically target the Freedom Foundation, an organization dedicated to informing government employees about their rights to reject union membership and dues.
Oregon’s law, enacted last year, forbids impersonating a union representative, with penalties of $6,250 per incident. In response, the Freedom Foundation filed a lawsuit, claiming the law suppresses free speech by equating their communication efforts to fraud. A federal district court initially dismissed their case, leading to an appeal to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
In New York, a similar measure, Civil Service Law Section 216, was passed. The law gives Attorney General Letitia James the power to intervene if she believes someone is about to engage in forbidden communication. Each violation may result in fines of $1,000. The Freedom Foundation sued New York in late September.
The constitutional concern lies not in prosecution but in preventing speech preemptively. Union advocates have not shown evidence of deception by the Freedom Foundation. Nevertheless, the organization faces the threat of accusations for potential misrepresentation or other deceptive practices.
This leads back to Janus. Since 2018, unions have implemented methods to complicate opting out of membership. The Freedom Foundation has assisted workers in breaking ties with unions and appealed to the Supreme Court multiple times for intervention. The court’s inaction has led unions and supportive legislators to test the decision’s boundaries, evidenced by the new laws in Oregon and New York.
These laws not only hinder employees from exercising their rights but also target the information needed for informed decision-making. The First Amendment does not cover fraud, but states can address any actual impersonation or deceitful actions. Despite this, allegations of fraud serve as a tool to silence differing opinions.
The outcome of these legal challenges is critical beyond the Freedom Foundation’s interests. One or both cases could reach the Supreme Court. If they do, it presents the justices an opportunity to assert the rights emphasized in Janus.
For eight years, the Supreme Court has mostly remained passive while unions tested the limits of Janus. A constitutional right undermined by governmental actions becomes meaningless. The justices set a precedent with Janus in 2018. They should make clear its enduring significance should Oregon or New York’s laws come before them.
Jeff Rhodes serves as vice president of news and information at the Freedom Foundation. Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
