October 22, 2026

Amanda Seyfried Criticized for Elizabeth Holmes Documentary Appearance

Amanda Seyfried has faced significant backlash following her participation in the latest Elizabeth Holmes documentary, “You Can See Everything.” The film, released on October 16, features Seyfried alongside Nathan Fielder, exploring the final 34 days before Holmes began her prison sentence on May 30, 2023.

Seyfried revisited her relationship with the Theranos founder, whom she portrayed in Hulu’s “The Dropout.” The documentary provides insight into Seyfried’s evolving view of Holmes, delving into aspects of Holmes’ personal life and her relationship with Billy Evans. In collaboration with Fielder, Seyfried helped recreate conversations he had with Holmes post-incarceration.

Amanda Seyfried faced backlash after her appearance in the new Elizabeth Holmes documentary drew accusations of hypocrisy among viewers.

Throughout the documentary, Seyfried grapples with her growing sympathy for Holmes. Viewers criticized her, accusing her of hypocrisy for defending Holmes while participating in a dramatized portrayal of the Theranos scandal.

A user on social media expressed disdain, writing, “Amanda Seyfried defending Holmes as a victim of male manipulation only to flip out when accused of sensationalizing the scandal was gross.” The sentiment echoed among other viewers, who felt Seyfried changed her stance when her role was scrutinized.

Some viewers argued that this behavior contradicted her purported support for women, claiming she deflected when faced with criticism. However, others defended Seyfried, suggesting her changing opinion was integral to the documentary’s narrative.

“Imagine blaming Amanda Seyfried,” wrote one viewer, supporting Seyfried’s evolving perspective. Another praised her willingness to confront potential consequences of her portrayal, despite believing she was not in the wrong.

Elizabeth Holmes was sentenced to 11 years and three months in federal prison after being found guilty in January 2022 on fraud charges related to misleading Theranos investors. “You Can See Everything” explores Holmes’ efforts to reshape her public image post-Theranos, as well as the divide between Holmes’ self-perception and public opinion.

TAGS: