A letter claiming to be from Jane Doe, who alleges gang rape at a Cornell fraternity event in 2024, was not shared with all faculty members, leading to concerns about transparency. Doe’s letter expresses feeling unsupported by Cornell’s president, Michael Kotlikoff, igniting controversy and a criminal review.
The letter, dated October 14, surfaced as the Faculty Senate debated a potential no-confidence vote in Kotlikoff’s leadership. In it, Doe insists on informing the faculty while not dictating their voting choices.
Three faculty sources informed CBS News New York’s Mahsa Saeidi they never received the letter from the administration. Risa Lieberwitz, a member of the Cornell Faculty Senate, highlighted the missed opportunity to directly question Kotlikoff due to this oversight.
“The Faculty Senate was not able to ask Kotlikoff about the letter, which silenced Jane Doe’s voice regarding assurance of support.”
The university explains the dean of faculty sent the letter to an independent review after verifying it with general counsel. However, concerns over transparency persist, as pointed out by Lieberwitz.
CBS News New York accessed the letter through a separate university source. It details a conversation involving Doe’s former sorority president, where Kotlikoff allegedly questioned Doe’s timing in coming forward, fostering her feeling of disbelief.
Doe’s attorney affirmed the letter’s authenticity, while Cornell disputes this account, asserting Kotlikoff questioned bystanders, not Doe. Faculty members insisted the letter should have reached them before discussions on a no-confidence vote set for October 24, where Kotlikoff won’t attend.
David Bateman of the American Association of University Professors supports the no-confidence vote, citing insufficient assurance of structural change within the university to accommodate serious dialogue with students and faculty.
Sally Yates, appointed to review Cornell’s procedures relating to sexual assault allegations, pledged to assess responses to Doe’s case and the university’s policies on sexual misconduct.
All seven accused men deny the allegations in Doe’s lawsuit.
