October 20, 2026

Munster Town Council Faces Leadership Change as Councilman Gardiner Resigns

The Munster Town Council is experiencing a shift in leadership due to an unexpected resignation. Councilman Chuck Gardiner announced at Monday night’s council meeting that he would step down after 6 ½ years serving as a councilman and member of the Redevelopment Commission. His resignation takes effect on Tuesday, Oct. 20.

Gardiner, who also held the position of Council Vice President for 2026, shared his thoughts through a letter during the meeting. In the letter, he expressed his admiration for the community’s ‘forward-thinking spirit’ and his gratitude for having contributed to it. He thanked residents for their support and praised town employees for their professionalism.

‘Overall, I have always believed that a community grounded in connection, optimism, and unity is far stronger than one driven by fear and division,’ Gardiner stated emotionally. He highlighted how the community came together during the crises of the 2020 pandemic and the 2026 EF1 tornado.

While Gardiner didn’t detail the reasons for his resignation in his letter, he told the Post-Tribune that frustration with council politics and discord were factors. ‘I’ve tried to be as thoughtful and as good a councilman as possible. I am burnt out,’ he said. Gardiner also mentioned not wanting to go through another campaign in a year and a half.

Lake County Republican Party Chairman Randy Niemeyer noted that Gardiner must formalize his resignation at the Lake County Clerk’s office before a replacement process can commence. Once submitted, the party will have 30 days to hold a caucus for selecting a successor.

Council President Joe Hofferth expressed sadness over Gardiner’s departure. ‘You worked hard, got involved, and built bridges. It’s sad to see you leave, but thank you for your service.’ Councilmen Dave Nellans and Jonathan Petersen also expressed gratitude for Gardiner’s contributions, while George Shinkan emphasized learning from Gardiner’s cooperative approach.

Shinkan, however, hinted at council issues in a social media post. He expressed concerns about division and urged the focus to return to the community’s well-being.

Shinkan’s post follows the resignation of Town attorneys Nicole Bennett and David Westland, who reported harassment by Petersen. Additionally, Town Manager James Marino retired, and Tricia Abbott was appointed as his replacement.

This resignation is one in a series since 2024, beginning with former Town Manager Dustin Anderson and Public Works Director Jill DiTommaso’s departures. Abbott initially filled in as interim manager before James Marino took over in 2025. DiTommaso’s successor, Robert Valois, also left Munster in 2026.

Michelle L. Quinn is a freelance reporter for the Post-Tribune.

TAGS: