Director Edward Hall’s production of The Winter’s Tale at the Chicago Shakespeare Theater marks the beginning of an innovative repertory approach. A group of actors is set to perform multiple plays simultaneously, offering consistent work and creative collaboration for some of Chicago’s veteran performers this season.
This initiative continues Hall’s interest in creating Shakespeare stagings that revolve around a dedicated troupe of actors. Historically, Shakespearean plays were produced with a consistent cast-size and recurring character types, and Hall’s approach echoes this tradition.
The opening of The Winter’s Tale on a recent Sunday afternoon is followed by a brief hiatus before performances resume. The company uses this time to rehearse for their upcoming production, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, set to open on November 15. Both plays will be part of a “rotating repertory”, a strategy similar to that of the Stratford Festival in Canada, which often deepens audience engagement.
While the initial reviews for The Winter’s Tale are positive, the full impact of this new repertory model will become clearer after the second opening. The current production, although featuring strong performances and engaging staging, might benefit from a more emotionally resonant portrayal.
For a play that often stirs deep emotions, this interpretation felt less impactful.
The Winter’s Tale, like others among Shakespeare’s late romances, explores themes of forgiveness and redemption. It centers on the rash actions of King Leontes of Sicilia, played by Demetrios Troy, whose jealousy leads to devastating consequences for his family and kingdom. Despite Leontes’ eventual repentance, the play’s climax carries a poignant mix of regret and hope.
An interesting casting choice in this production is the doubling of roles — Felicia Oduh plays both Perdita and Mamillius. This complicates the narrative’s emotional depth, especially during the final scenes. Hall’s reluctance to offer Leontes any form of absolution diverges from traditional interpretations which suggest a theme of hopeful redemption without absolute forgiveness.
The early scenes, depicting Leontes’ unfounded accusations, are executed effectively. They resonate with modern parallels where truth-tellers remain silent out of fear. Kevin Gudahl, Sean Fortunato, and Erik Hellman portray these helpless courtiers convincingly, while Issy Van Randwyck as Paulina stands firm in courage.
In the Bohemian scenes, Hall imagines a lively, musical landscape, complete with a band and joyful dance. Despite its entertainment value, these scenes risk distracting from the play’s pivotal emotional turning points.
This production, however, excels in clarity and aesthetics. The visual design is elegant, thanks to the work of Michael Pavelka on costumes and set. The performance is never dull, with engaging direction and delivery throughout.
The stakes in The Winter’s Tale are high, involving themes of error and regret, yet they require fuller representation in this staging. It is hoped that future performances in the repertory will bring these elements more vividly to the forefront.
Review: “The Winter’s Tale” (3 stars)
When: Through Dec. 12
Where: Chicago Shakespeare’s Courtyard Theater on Navy Pier
Running time: 2 hours, 40 minutes
Tickets: $65-$135 at 312-595-5600 and chicagoshakes.com
