October 15, 2026

A Comparison of The Dodgers’ Postseason Struggles to The Godfather III

The Los Angeles Dodgers find themselves in a challenging 0-3 position in their series, likened to ‘The Godfather: Part III’ by FS1 host Colin Cowherd. He draws parallels between the Dodgers’ attempt at a third World Series victory and the cinematic experience of the trilogy’s third installment.

Colin Cowherd stated, ‘The Dodgers trying to win a third World Series is starting to have Godfather III vibes to it. Some of the names are familiar – Al Pacino, Diane Keaton, Francis Ford Coppola is still directing. But it feels played. And the Dodgers feel played out.’ This analogy highlights the struggle of a once-great entity trying to replicate past success.

Andy Garcia and Al Pacino feature in ‘The Godfather: Part III,’ a movie both directed and written by Francis Ford Coppola. Before applying this analogy broadly, Cowherd cautions against directly equating the players with the actors. Al Pacino delivered an excellent performance in the film, whereas Shohei Ohtani, although renowned as a top baseball player, struggles in the postseason. Ohtani’s batting average has dipped below .200 in four consecutive postseason games, leading to discussions about benching him in Game 3 due to his performance and injuries.

If the Dodgers fail to recover from their 0-3 deficit, they would only be the second MLB team to do so in an LCS series, reinforcing the analogy’s relevance.

‘The Godfather’ and ‘The Godfather Part II’ are celebrated as cinematic masterpieces, arguably among the greatest films ever. ‘Part II’ serves as both sequel and prequel, ranking high in these assessments. Although ‘Part III’ isn’t inadequate as some critics suggest, it doesn’t match the legacy of its predecessors.

Several factors contributed to ‘Part III’s’ underwhelming reception. Sofia Coppola took on the role of Mary Corleone, a decision that proved ineffective. The romance between Mary and Vincent occupied excessive screen time without significantly impacting the trilogy’s conclusion. The absence of essential characters like Tom Hagen and Sonny Corleone further detracted from the film’s impact.

The Dodgers, like ‘The Godfather’ series, would likely be regarded more fondly if the 2026 team wasn’t included. Nostalgic fans often skip ‘Part III’ during marathons.

Examining excuses behind ‘Part III’s’ shortcomings, the film released 16 years post-‘Part II,’ allowing significant aging among the cast. Robert Duvall did not reprise his role as Hagen, and expectations soared to near unattainable levels.

Conversely, the 2026 Dodgers have no justification. Their payroll outstrips those of the other remaining teams combined. Tarik Skubal and Kyle Tucker joined an already elite roster. Yet, similar to ‘Part III,’ the Dodgers’ aging cast struggles to regain their former glory.

Even Ian Miller, a Dodgers superfan, and OutKick reporter, finds Cowherd’s analogy impressive, acknowledging the accolades of ‘The Godfather’ series and the Dodgers’ earlier successes.

He adds an important caveat, urging avoidance of creating another disappointing installment akin to ‘Megalopolis’ next year.

TAGS: