A group of 72 retired military generals and leaders has called on the Trump administration to stop plans for the livestream execution of Fort Hood shooter, Nidal Malik Hasan. Hasan, an Army psychiatrist, was found guilty of murdering 13 individuals during a shooting at the Fort Hood military base in 2009.
President Donald Trump approved Hasan’s execution by firing squad earlier in October, with the Army setting the date for December 3. The Pentagon later announced that the event would be livestreamed. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth stated this decision stemmed from the desire for a public execution.
“We urge the President, our Congressional representatives, and fellow citizens to prevent this unethical misuse of authority: Livestreaming an execution is contrary to the principles and values of our military and nation.”
In an open letter provided by Just Security, the retired military officers emphasized that the death sentence was agreed upon unanimously in the court-martial. It remains the government’s duty to ensure the execution adheres to constitutional values.
The authors argued that livestreaming violates the Eighth Amendment, which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. They insist that the Army regulation on execution ensures this responsibility. Livestreaming “would clearly demean the fundamental human dignity of the condemned” and transform a grave punishment into a spectacle for onlookers.
The letter warns that such an event could diminish the military’s honor while stigmatizing the nation allowing it. Additionally, it cautions against potential use by foreign adversaries to incite hostility, posing risks to U.S. soldiers and civilian lives while creating a martyr out of Hasan.
Newsweek reached out to the White House and the Pentagon but received no response outside regular business hours.
The signatories include prominent figures such as General Johnnie Wilson, USA (Ret), Lieutenant-General Charles P. Otstott, and many others.
Trump’s Response
Trump, a capital punishment advocate, acknowledged his approval of the livestream execution. “Did I approve? Absolutely,” he confirmed to reporters. The president is considering whether to rescind the livestream plan, as reported by CNN.
Upon learning Hasan is paralyzed from the waist down, Trump reportedly found public execution less palatable. A Trump adviser mentioned concerns that the broadcast could serve as extremist propaganda. The president acknowledged the pros and cons of showing the execution and stated, “I know what the military would like to do, but we’ll make a decision.”
Broad Opposition
Opposition to the livestreaming plan extends beyond politics. Archbishop Paul Coakley, representing the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, denounced it as “a barbaric promotion of a culture of death.”
Execution Details
The Army announced Hasan’s execution at Fort Hood in Texas set for December 3 at 1 p.m. Hasan attacked soldiers in a medical building, claiming it was to prevent deployments to Afghanistan.
After admitting to the attack during a 2013 court-martial, Hasan received a death sentence. His appeals ended after the Supreme Court refused his case in March 2025. Authorization for the execution by firing squad followed in October under Trump.
The execution method hasn’t been used since World War II, with Hegseth noting military executions hadn’t occurred since Army Private John Bennett’s hanging in 1961.
Restrictions on Witnesses
Army Regulation 190-55 outlines witness eligibility for military executions, excluding public attendance. Authorized witnesses include designated military members, the execution team, the condemned’s attorney, along with invited family and media representatives.
John Galligan, a former military judge, confirmed that the regulation restricts general public access, allowing media presence under strict conditions. Galligan critiqued the inadequacy in understanding around execution procedures.
Though details of the firing squad execution are sparse, the Army assures compliance with regulations according to the Associated Press.
