An appeals court sided with the Trump administration, temporarily halting a part of a California law. This law required federal law enforcement in plainclothes to display badges and identification during operations. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals found the Trump administration’s lawsuit against California was strong, stating that California’s identification requirement in the No Vigilantes Act breaches the Constitution’s supremacy clause. This clause gives precedence to federal over state law when conflicts arise.
The court stated, “Section 10 explicitly overrides the federal government’s power to determine whether, how, and when to publicly identify its officers.” This decision comes from a court that has often opposed the Trump administration, blocking numerous immigration policies, such as federal funding withdrawal from sanctuary cities in 2018 and changes to asylum eligibility the same year.
“Section 10 explicitly overrides the federal government’s power,” stated the appeals court.
The ruling presents a setback for California’s Governor Gavin Newsom. Newsom, a prominent opponent of Trump’s immigration policies, has enacted laws to protect immigrant communities and limit federal immigration operations. The legal battle initiated when the Trump administration sued California in 2025 over the No Vigilantes Act and No Secret Police Act, which limits officers from wearing face coverings. Initially, Judge Christina Snyder blocked facial covering restrictions but allowed the identification requirement. The administration then appealed, resulting in the 9th Circuit’s temporary block.
California defended its law, arguing it did not unconstitutionally impact federal operations since substantial burdens must be shown for such rulings. However, the appeals court disagreed, emphasizing that state power cannot directly govern federal actions and stating, “The burden of the regulation on federal operations, whether substantial or otherwise, is irrelevant.”
“The burden of the regulation on federal operations, whether substantial or otherwise, is irrelevant,” the court added.
Trump administration members celebrated the ruling. Brett Shumate of the Justice Department emphasized, “The Ninth Circuit agrees that California cannot regulate federal law enforcement,” adding his thoughts on social platform X. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, Jr. also praised the decision, noting, “Today’s decision is a huge WIN for protecting the safety of our nation’s law enforcement officers.”
Efforts to contact Newsom’s office for a comment remain unanswered. Elaine Mallon, who reports on national politics for Fox News Digital and Fox Business, prepared this report.
