When the U.S. imposed tariffs on China in April 2025, Beijing’s response was to restrict exports of rare earth elements and magnets, impacting supply chains worldwide. In February, strikes by the U.S. and Israel against Iran led Tehran to expand the battlefield to the Gulf states. Recently, European Union defense ministers convened in Brussels to address the increasing threat of grey-zone attacks. Even the typically reserved Swiss government is voicing concerns over Russian actions. The discovery of an explosive-laden drone in August at Germany’s Leipzig Airport highlights a broader pattern: China, Iran, and Russia are employing horizontal escalation to challenge U.S. influence.
Understanding Horizontal Escalation
Horizontal escalation involves extending a conflict to new geographic regions or areas of competition, posing a complex challenge for U.S. policymakers. Washington’s strategy typically organizes policies vertically, focusing on distinct areas such as NATO, trade policy, and Taiwan. Conversely, adversaries like China, Russia, and Iran operate across these domains. Though their capabilities and aims differ, they share a common goal of disrupting the U.S.-led international order. Xi Jinping’s rhetoric about “major changes unseen in a century,” often underscores this intent, notably echoed alongside Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Cooperation Among U.S. Adversaries
America’s opponents sometimes collaborate to further their objectives. Tehran has supplied Moscow with critical drone technology in times of need, while Russia has reciprocated with advanced military assistance, reportedly aiding Iran in developing supersonic cruise missiles. China complicates U.S. pressure on Russia and Iran by providing Moscow with crucial dual-use items and remaining a significant buyer of Iranian oil despite sanctions. These actions absorb American resources, limiting their deployment elsewhere and revealing vulnerabilities in U.S. power.
Addressing Horizontal Escalation
U.S. alliances bolster American strength and extend its reach globally. However, this network also multiplies potential targets for adversaries. By threatening weaker allies or sabotaging infrastructure, they sidestep direct confrontation with the U.S. To counter these threats, the U.S. and its allies must reduce easy opportunities for horizontal escalation. They should diversify vulnerabilities, reinforce what cannot be diversified, maintain robust stocks of scarce military assets, and demand greater contributions from allies.
Beyond resilience, Washington and its allies should develop their own horizontal escalation strategies. Acts of sabotage by Russia against European infrastructure should result in severe consequences in areas valued by the Kremlin, such as interference with Russian financial activities and asset seizures related to sanctions evasion. The principle is that adversaries may choose where pressure is applied, but not where consequences will be felt.
Strategies in Economic and Grey-Zone Conflicts
Economic coercion does not always require an economic response, nor should grey-zone attacks only be answered at their origin. U.S. responses should instill doubt in adversaries about how the U.S. will retaliate. In instances like the Leipzig Airport drone discovery, Germany leveraged the situation by sending additional air defense missiles and drones to Ukraine.
Responding to actions from China, Iran, and Russia involves fostering uncertainty in their decision-making. Horizontal escalation strategies can unite U.S. allies around shared threats. For example, China’s retaliation to tariffs by disrupting European supply chains prompted Washington to establish a critical minerals partnership with Europe.
Building Stronger Alliances
As China supports Iran and Russia aids North Korea, concerned nations like Gulf states and America’s Asian allies might reevaluate their relations with Beijing and Moscow. Thus, adversaries inadvertently strengthen coalitions against them. Combating horizontal escalation calls for allies to stay vigilant against sabotage, shoulder more deterrence responsibilities, and coordinate to safeguard crucial technologies and supply chains. American leadership and reliability are essential to maintain openness as a strength for the West, not a weakness.
In conclusion, America’s adversaries have adapted to exploit horizontal avenues in conflict. The U.S. and its allies must demonstrate readiness to confront challenges similarly.
