Boston Red Sox pitcher Sonny Gray delivered a strong performance in the recent loss to the New York Yankees. Despite his solid showing, Gray expressed dissatisfaction with the timing of his removal by manager Chad Tracy.

Gray pitched 4.2 innings, allowing two earned runs and striking out five batters before receiving the loss. He was pulled from the game in the fifth inning after allowing a hit to Yankees’ top hitter Ben Rice, placing runners at first and third bases. Manager Tracy decided to bring in Erik Miller, who immediately gave up a single that scored another run for the Yankees. The game ended with the Red Sox falling 9-2.

I think I’m the best pitcher in the American League the third time through the order, Gray said after the game. I think that’s a fact. I would have liked to be trusted in that moment.

Gray’s confidence in his pitching during later innings is backed by his performance stats for 2026. He recorded a 1.99 ERA in 162 plate appearances against batters facing him the third time through the order. These figures ranked him second and fourth in the American League and MLB, respectively, with only Kumar Rocker, Chris Sale, and Eduardo Rodriguez posting better numbers.

How Did Sonny Gray Perform in 2026?

A three-time All-Star and 14-year MLB veteran, Gray had an impressive season in 2026. He maintained a 2.72 ERA over 29 starts and accumulated a 4.3 bWAR, marking his highest since 2023 during his time with the Minnesota Twins. With 18 wins, Gray led all MLB pitchers and proved to be a reliable starter for the Red Sox, especially during the absence of All-Star Garrett Crochet.

With a mutual option for the upcoming season, Gray’s future with Boston remains uncertain. After the game, he admitted uncertainty about staying in Boston if he doesn’t choose retirement. Fans await Gray’s decision as he considers his career path.