Elmo, the beloved Muppet from “Sesame Street,” typically brings smiles, not controversy. Yet Knicks fans found themselves upset with Elmo for not choosing a side in the NBA Finals. Elmo decided to avoid further backlash by expressing some support in a different arena.

During the USMNT’s game against Australia, Elmo made a choice and rooted for Team USA. The little red character declared, “Just to be clear, Elmo wants Team USA to win, okay? Elmo loves everybody. Just to be clear. Don’t make this a thing. Thank you.” This statement came as a lighthearted attempt to clear any doubts and prevent a repeat uproar.

The Muppets don’t often find themselves handling public image crises. The last major scrutiny was over Bert and Ernie’s curious living arrangement. However, Elmo’s recent experiences suggest a shift. The Knicks fans’ reaction mirrored the frenzy of the Tickle Me Elmo days, but this time, it wasn’t excitement behind the attention.

Elmo and Cookie Monster also attended the 2026 FIFA World Cup Opening Ceremony in Los Angeles, showcasing their love for global events. If sports fans embrace Elmo, he might emerge as a newfound mascot. Yet, should things turn unfavorable, Elmo’s popularity could take a hit, much like his run-in with Knicks fans.

Such an outcome might be harsh on the amiable Muppet, but his backing of Team USA suggests a strategic alignment with a passionate fan base.